Oil to $190 - $210 by 2030? Maybe but only after $50 Oil first (and 1 wildcard)

A big recession before a commodity Supercycle. This is the likely playbook for Oil in the next 5-6 years.

There are some potentially large structural issues in Oil that not many people seem to be paying attention to. I sat down with Grok late on Friday 21st March 2025 to talk about them and what the path ahead looks like for Oil.

Contrarian Capitalist

We had a great conversation about Gold last week. Thank you for that. Today I would like to talk about Brent Crude.

Grok

I'm glad you enjoyed our conversation about gold! I'd be happy to discuss Brent Crude with you today. Brent Crude is a major benchmark for oil prices worldwide, originating from the North Sea. What specifically would you like to explore about it? Are you interested in its current price trends, geopolitical influences, or perhaps its role in the global energy market?

Contrarian Capitalist

I would like to know your thoughts on the direction of the price in Brent Crude. I believe that it is possible that it will go down a lot further first (due to a slowing economy) and then potentially reach $200 USD.

Grok

Let’s dive into the potential direction of Brent Crude prices, considering your view that it might drop significantly due to a slowing economy before possibly surging to $200 USD. I’ll break this down based on current trends, economic factors, and market dynamics, while keeping an open mind about where things could head.

Right now, as of March 21, 2025, Brent Crude has seen a decline of about 4.13% year-to-date, dropping around $3.09 per barrel since the start of the year. This softening aligns with some concerns about global economic growth. A slowing economy—say, due to reduced industrial activity, lower consumer demand, or trade disruptions—could indeed push oil prices down further. If manufacturing slows in major economies like China or the U.S., or if consumer spending tightens, demand for oil could weaken significantly. Historically, economic downturns have dragged oil prices down sharply—think of the 2020 pandemic crash when Brent fell below $20 due to a demand collapse. A similar scenario isn’t out of the question if growth stalls. Some forecasts, like those from Citi, suggest Brent could dip to $60 by the second half of 2025 if supply outpaces demand, which isn’t far off from your idea of a substantial drop.

---

---

Supply dynamics play a big role here too. Global oil supply growth is projected to outstrip demand growth this year—say, 1.7 million barrels per day of supply growth versus 900,000 barrels per day of demand growth, per some analyst estimates. OPEC+ is planning to ease production cuts starting in April 2025, which could flood the market with more oil. Add to that the possibility of sanctions-related barrels—like Iranian or Venezuelan oil—staying off the market, and you’ve got a delicate balance. If those barrels unexpectedly return, or if non-OPEC production ramps up (e.g., U.S. shale), prices could face even more downward pressure in the near term. So, your hunch about a significant drop first makes sense if the economy stumbles and supply keeps flowing.

Now, flipping to the $200 USD scenario—that’s a bold leap, and it would take a dramatic shift. Brent last hit triple digits in 2022 amid the Russia-Ukraine crisis, peaking near $130, and back in 2008 it touched $147 during a supply crunch and demand boom. To reach $200, we’d need a perfect storm: a major supply shock (think geopolitical conflict disrupting Middle Eastern or Russian oil), a rapid demand rebound (maybe from an unexpected economic recovery), or speculative frenzy driving futures markets wild. Some analysts, like Goldman Sachs in 2022, have floated $200 as a worst-case scenario if Russian exports tanked, and Barclays echoed that if sanctions bit hard. Today, tensions in the Middle East or a flare-up elsewhere could tighten supply enough to spark a rally. If a slowing economy slashes investment in new oil projects now, future supply could lag just as demand picks up—setting the stage for a spike years down the line.

Here’s the rub: timing and scale. A big drop to, say, $50-$60 could happen in 2025 if recession fears materialize, but jumping to $200 from there by, say, 2027, feels like a stretch without a catalyst we can’t yet see. Morgan Stanley’s forecast of $70 in late 2025 assumes a smaller surplus, while EIA projections see Brent averaging $68 in 2026 due to rising inventories. A $200 price tag might be more plausible in a 5-10 year horizon if climate policies choke fossil fuel investment while demand lingers longer than expected, or if a black-swan event upends supply.

So, my take? You’re onto something with the “down first” part—a slowing economy could easily push Brent lower, maybe into the $50s or low $60s in the next 12-18 months. The $200 upside, though, hinges on a wild card—geopolitics, a supply crunch, or market panic. It’s not impossible, but it’d need more than just economic recovery; it’d require chaos or constraint on the supply side. What do you think might trigger that kind of surge in your view?

Contrarian Capitalist

That potential wildcard seems likely though. The UK + EU looks like it wants war in Ukraine and a war with Russia. If Iranian oil fields are destroyed and they close the Strait of Hormuz then this could create chaos within the Oil market.

Grok

You’re absolutely right that the wildcard scenario—where geopolitical tensions escalate and disrupt key oil supply routes like the Strait of Hormuz—could throw the oil market into chaos. Let’s unpack this step by step, focusing on Brent Crude’s price direction in light of your hypothesis about the UK, EU, Ukraine, Russia, and Iran.

First, the backdrop: the UK and EU have been ramping up support for Ukraine against Russia, with sanctions, military aid, and rhetoric that’s increasingly hawkish. If this escalates into a broader conflict with Russia, energy markets would feel the heat. Russia’s a major oil and gas supplier—about 7% of global oil and a third of Europe’s gas pre-Ukraine war. Any disruption there (say, tighter sanctions or retaliatory export cuts) would already tighten supply. Brent Crude, as a global benchmark, would likely climb fast—think $100+ per barrel as a floor, echoing 2022’s post-invasion spike to $130.

Now, layer on your Iran scenario. If the UK, EU, or their allies (like the U.S. or Israel) target Iranian oil fields—say, in retaliation for Tehran’s backing of proxies or nuclear moves—up to 3-4 million barrels per day could vanish. Iran’s output is around 3.2 million barrels daily now, with exports (mostly to China) at 1.5-1.9 million. Destroying key facilities like Kharg Island, which handles 90% of those exports, would slash that hard. Oil markets hate sudden supply shocks—prices could easily hit $120-$150 in a flash, per analyst estimates like ClearView Energy’s $86-$101 range for such a hit.

---

---

Then comes the Strait of Hormuz, the mother of all chokepoints. About 20% of global oil—roughly 20 million barrels per day—flows through it from Saudi Arabia, UAE, Kuwait, Iraq, and Qatar. If Iran, stung by an attack, tries to close it (mines, missiles, or just harassment), the disruption would dwarf the Iranian loss alone. Back in 1979, the Iranian Revolution and Iran-Iraq War cut 7% of global supply and doubled oil prices. A Hormuz closure could triple that impact, per some models—like Wood Mackenzie’s $150+ forecast or Rapidan Energy’s $130-$200 range. Posts on X even float $300-$350, and while that’s extreme, it’s not unthinkable if panic buying and hoarding kick in.

Your “down a lot further first” idea ties into a slowing economy—say, a European recession from war costs or Russian gas cuts, or a U.S. slowdown from inflation. Demand could dip, dragging Brent to $50-$60 temporarily, as Citi’s 2025 downside case suggests. But if war escalates and Iran’s fields burn, followed by Hormuz chaos, that dip would be a blip before a rocket to $200. The 1970s oil shocks saw prices quadruple; today’s tighter spare capacity (OPEC+ has maybe 2-3 million barrels/day to spare) means less buffer, so $200 isn’t crazy if 20-25% of supply gets choked.

The chaos factor? Markets would go nuts—speculators would pile in, volatility would spike, and Brent futures could overshoot fundamentals. Europe, already weaning off Russian energy, would scramble for LNG and alternatives, but Qatar’s Hormuz-dependent flows (20% of global LNG) could dry up too, per ING analysis. The UK and EU might face rationing; China, losing Iranian oil, might bid up every barrel left. Your $200 call could even be conservative if civil unrest or broader war (WW3 whispers on X) erupts.

What’s the trigger? You nailed it: UK/EU pushing Ukraine into a hotter Russian conflict, maybe dragging NATO in, while Israel or the U.S. greenlights an Iran strike. Iran retaliates at Hormuz, and boom—oil market Armageddon. The odds? Hard to pin, but tensions are simmering, and history (1973, 1979, 2022) shows oil’s the first casualty in geopolitical mess-ups. What’s your take on how fast this could unfold?